Introduction
Jaxson Dart was the 25th pick in the 2025 draft, and I wasn’t a fan of the pick at the time. Late first-round quarterbacks rarely hit, and for a rebuilding franchise, missing on a first-rounder can set things back years. My concerns with Dart were clear. While he had athleticism, toughness, and arm talent, he played in a true college system. The Ole Miss offense was built on RPOs and schemed-open receivers, which meant he rarely had to read full NFL-style coverages.
On tape at Ole Miss, Dart looked sharp when the pocket was clean and his first read was there. But once pressured or forced deeper into progressions, his performance dipped. That doesn’t mean he can’t develop into an NFL quarterback. He simply wasn’t asked to do certain things in college. Week 4 was his first real test, going against one of the league’s top defenses. He came away with a win. I broke down the All-22 to see how Dart really performed in his NFL debut.
First Quarter
All Dropbacks are linked with the All-22
Quarter Overview
The Giants established their run game early. Dart himself contributed three strong carries, including a 15-yard touchdown run. Pass protection also held up well, giving Dart time to work. He looked comfortable early, mixing RPO decisions with clean reads.
Key Dropbacks
- Dropback 1 → Cover 2 man. RPO with Nabers on a go as the pass option. Dart reads the safety, sees him stay shallow, and throws the go. The throw is short and draws DPI. Correct read, but the ball needed more air and better placement.
- Dropback 2 → Quarters coverage. Daboll schemes the first read wide open. The inside WR slant takes the LB, the RB flat pulls the safety, leaving Nabers free on a hitch. Dart throws decisively for 9 yards. Clean read and accuracy.
- Dropback 3 → Chargers drop nine into coverage. First read Nabers slant, not open, so Dart turns it down. Robinson, available for a small gain, also turned down. Pocket holds, Dart steps up, draws LBs, and rips it to Nabers. Great awareness to manipulate defenders, but accuracy limited YAC.
- Dropback 4 → 3rd-and-6 from own 4. Cover 2 man. Dart sees a lane, scrambles, motions to Slayton to come back, and throws on the run for a first. Excellent playmaking and poise.
- Dropback 6 → Cover 1 man. First read Robinson whip, covered. Goes to 1v1 on the outside, throws a go. The ball drifts a little too much towards the sideline, the WR can’t finish. Reads were covered; this was the best option.
- Dropback 7 → Cover 2 zone. Dart peeks weak side, doesn’t like it. Strong side has Nabers on a corner and Robinson on an out. Pocket muddy but had a chance to drift left and hit Nabers in a tight window. Instead, Dart turns it down, panics, and takes a sack.
Quarter Analysis
The run game was explosive, capped by Dart’s 15-yard rushing touchdown. Pass protection was solid, and Dart looked comfortable on scripted plays. His best moment came on the Slayton scramble-drill completion. But he also panicked in a clean look on Dropback 7, a reminder that his progression work remains a weakness.
Second Quarter
Quarter Overview
Pass protection continued to hold up, but the run game slowed. Dart showed flashes of command at the line and quick decision-making. A few moments of hesitation and overconfidence cost him plays.
Key Dropbacks
- Dropback 8 → Simulated pressure with DT dropping, LB bluffing. First read Nabers slant is there early, but Dart holds it too long. LB drops under it, pressure wins, and Dart is sacked. Dart needed decisiveness on this play.
- Dropback 9 → Cover 6. First read Robinson is not open. Dart climbs the pocket and hits TE on a stop for 10. Strong pocket movement.
- Dropback 10 → Cover 3, designed rollout. Nabers clears the safety. Skateboo wheel vs LB is open. Dart faces immediate pressure and throws inaccurately. Good read, but missed execution.
- Dropback 12 → Cover 3. Pressure pushes Dart up in the pocket, and he scrambles for 11. Athletic play, but Robinson was open on a dig if Dart resets. Still a first down.
- Dropback 14 → Uses cadence to bait blitz look, then checks into a new play. Throws post to Slayton, who is held, drawing DPI. Excellent pre-snap IQ.
- Dropback 15 → Designed rollout. Free rusher comes. Robinson comes open in the flat for a possible score. Dart tries to outrun the rusher, but takes a sack. Needed to throw it quickly.
Quarter Analysis
Dart showed command with cadence and play checks, highlighted by the Slayton DPI. His pocket movement looked natural at times, but hesitation on Dropback 8 and stubbornness on Dropback 15 stalled drives. The run game slowed, forcing him to win more with his arm.
Third Quarter
Quarter Overview
Dart missed one drive, and the Chargers controlled possession. When on the field, the Giants’ protection was strong, and the run game regained momentum. Dart had a limited sample this quarter, with accuracy issues creeping in.
Key Dropbacks
- Dropback 16 → Cover 2 zone with man. Robinson is wide open on a slant, Dart turns it down, and scrambles for similar yardage. Athletic gain, but missed an easy throw.
- Dropback 17 → 3rd down from own 1. Cover 3. First read Robinson quickly out, open, but Dart throws at his feet. Poor execution.
- Dropback 18 → Fake toss into seam and backside dig. TE seam open, but Dart looks for a moment, then abandons it. Sack follows. Misreading cost him.
Quarter Analysis
Dart’s athleticism created gains, but he turned down layups and missed simple throws. Accuracy faltered, and one poor progression choice turned into a sack. Limited volume, but a step back compared to earlier.
Fourth Quarter
Quarter Overview
The Giants leaned on the ground game, with pass protection still strong. Dart was asked to make a few throws, mixing quick reads with improvisation under pressure.
Key Dropbacks
- Dropback 19 → Cover 2 zone. Inside WR slant pulls LB, RB flat pulls safety. Hitch wide open. Dart is decisive, throws quickly for 17. Clean rep.
- Dropback 20 → Quarters coverage. First read Robinson out, covered. The second read deep stop comes open late, but pressure hits first. Sack. Should have dirted it instead of taking negative play.
- Dropback 21 → Cover 3. The first two reads are not there, but the stop route is open all the way. Dart doesn’t get there, scrambles for 2. Needed faster progression.
- Dropback 22 → Cover 6. Same slant-flat combo as Dropback 19. Dart takes the hitch for a gain, but Robinson’s crosser behind it was open for a TD. Safe play, but missed a bigger chance.
- Dropback 23 → 4th-and-goal rollout. Everything is covered frontside and the backside is also covered. Dart makes a man miss, manipulates defenders, and lobs it to Robinson. DB breaks it up. Athletic creativity nearly saves the play.
Quarter Analysis
Pass protection stayed solid, and the run game came alive again. Dart made good use of quick-game concepts, but he also missed multiple open throws and continued to lean on his legs when progressions bogged down. His best late moment came on Dropback 23, showing the athleticism that made him a first-rounder.
Technical Takeaways
- Athleticism
Dart’s mobility bailed out several plays and added rushing production, highlighted by his 15-yard touchdown run and multiple scrambles. - Progressions
Too often turned down open first or second reads, instead scrambling or forcing plays. Improvement here is critical. - Accuracy
Flashes of sharp ball placement, but inconsistency showed with missed slants and low throws, particularly in the third quarter.
Final Thoughts
Jaxson Dart’s NFL debut showed both why the Giants believed in him and why there were doubts. He thrived when plays were on time and protection held, flashing athleticism and toughness. But he left yards on the field by turning down simple reads and showed inconsistency in accuracy when pressured.
Even with his flaws, Dart walked away with a win over an elite defense. If the Giants continue to build around his athleticism and simplify his reads, there’s room for growth. His ceiling remains tied to his development in reading coverages and delivering accurate throws consistently.
If you liked this I will be posting a All-22 review every week this season!
Leave a Reply